Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
The Auto-Sleeper Motorhome Owners Forum (ASOF) :: Auto-Sleeper Motorhome Forums :: Auto-Sleeper "Coachbuilt Motorhomes" Forum
Page 3 of 8 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
I wonder if they had it done as a precaution and if it raises the weight limit from 50kg incl. the rack to 60kg excl. the rack? If they had it done because the rack had dropped off and they had kept within A-S's weight restrictions, I would have thought it would have been covered under warranty or as a gesture of good will. Whatever, £70 sounds very reasonable.Paulmold wrote:Just seen this follow-up on FB to the rack-coming-away problem ...
"We finally had the bike rack fix done today at Marquis Plymouth on our Nuevo. We were the first guinea pigs there but it is done. Two large bolts through the rack, back wall of motorhome, thick bit of wood and metal plate seemingly. £70.
Fingers crossed that is now sorted."
Caraman- Member
-
Posts : 3689
Joined : 2019-04-19
Location : SALISBURY
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
MrsCC’s bike is just a Mi-Rider but I have a heavier Haibike which were fine on our last Broadway bike rack as checked & confirmed by Mark at Auto Sleepers when he was there.
Thinking I may have to invest in a smaller lightweight e-bike, but still concerned at a bike rack that in my very limited engineering or technical knowledge or understanding is just glued to a shiny plastic surface, surely a recipe for disaster
_________________
Get a life..... Get an Auto-Sleeper!
CC- Moderator
-
Posts : 3844
Joined : 2011-02-05
Member Age : 59
Location : North Norfolk
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
My Haibike weighs 22kg & MrsCC’s Mi-Rider weighs 17.5kg so a combined weight of 39.3kg I’m guessing with the battery packs removed (if these are included in the weights specified) the weight would be slightly lower, slightly under 39kg ??
So would others agree that with these bike weights our Broadway’s bike rack should be able to cope ok without ripping itself off as I’m really worried now after reading the original post by Bowlertilt
_________________
Get a life..... Get an Auto-Sleeper!
CC- Moderator
-
Posts : 3844
Joined : 2011-02-05
Member Age : 59
Location : North Norfolk
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
Caraman- Member
-
Posts : 3689
Joined : 2019-04-19
Location : SALISBURY
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
CC likes this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
_________________
Get a life..... Get an Auto-Sleeper!
CC- Moderator
-
Posts : 3844
Joined : 2011-02-05
Member Age : 59
Location : North Norfolk
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
If you do a Forum search you will find quite a bit on lighting boards. My very first post in 2019 was about it. I can't remember all the details but the lighting regulations require both vertical sets of rear lights to be viewable from the rear at an angle on either side of the van. The regulations stipulate what that angle is. I think its 45 degrees. If you have a cover on your bikes it will prevent the lights being viewed from one side or the other. If you don't fit a cover, the bike frame, rims, tyres and rear marker board may still obscure the lights sufficiently to be picked up by a zealous policeman in this country or abroad. If you don't have a lighting board fitted, whether you have a cover or not, and are involved in some way in an accident, it puts you in a bad place in my opinion. The CAMC advice is here:CC wrote:... would have a bike cover fitted and marker board no doubt but won’t be using a lighting board.
https://www.caravanclub.co.uk/advice-and-training/technical-advice/cycle-carriers/
My lighting board is about 2 kg as is my cover and my marker board is about 1 kg so all 3 together is about 5 kg.
The lighting board is cheap and easy to fit if the VLM5 unit is used.
This wan't a problem with older vans where the lights were lower and bike rack higher.
Last edited by Caraman on Thu Jun 20, 2024 2:36 pm; edited 3 times in total
Caraman- Member
-
Posts : 3689
Joined : 2019-04-19
Location : SALISBURY
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
frederic
frederic- Donator
-
Posts : 1374
Joined : 2011-11-15
Member Age : 78
Location : Stranraer, Wigtownshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : Topaz TipT
Vehicle Year : 2008
CC likes this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
Caraman- Member
-
Posts : 3689
Joined : 2019-04-19
Location : SALISBURY
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
frederic likes this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
frederic wrote:Has anyone thought about the 'Shock Load' when hitting a pothole or speed bump? this surely would increase the loading on the bond in excess of 50/60kg.
frederic
Agree very worrying Frederic, have to say I’m extremely disappointed with this solution by Auto Sleepers bearing in mind the severity of what could potentially happen in the event the rack fails. I’m very uncomfortable using ours, knowing what I now know.
I’m also wondering how our insurance companies would view this failure in the event of an incident like this, two bikes & a bike rack falling into the path of a vehicle behind could have absolutely devastating consequences & even cause fatalities if someone veered off the road to avoid hitting them
_________________
Get a life..... Get an Auto-Sleeper!
CC- Moderator
-
Posts : 3844
Joined : 2011-02-05
Member Age : 59
Location : North Norfolk
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2019
Cymro and frederic like this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
With a coachbuilt or monocoque it might be quite easy to fit a couple of stainless steel eyes to the bodywork to take a ratchet strap and hold the bikes (and rack!) more securely. It won’t improve the load capacity of course but it will stop the bikes bouncing and may prevent a catastrophic accident. For me at least it would be a lot of extra peace of mind whilst driving, especially if you have the slightest doubt about the security of the rack. I keep well back from MH’s with bikes on the back now, since this thread started!
The Bargee- Member
-
Posts : 651
Joined : 2022-12-27
Location : Rugby
Auto-Sleeper Model : Kingham
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
"In order that a cycle rack and/or rear ladder can be fitted the rear panel bodywork is reinforced in certain areas. Vertical and horizontal timbers have been bonded into the panel to take the fixings for these items."
No mention is made of weight limits but the Fiamma rack has a load limit of 60 kg so it's reasonable to assume that the weight limit on the fixings is 60 kg plus the weight of the rack (7.5 kg or 10 kg for the e-bike model). So a cycle load (including covers, locks and marker board) of up to 60 kg can be carried, there being no need for a lighting board. I wonder if the fixings have been bolted through as per the Fiamma installation manual in which case Cymro may have nothing to worry about.
The manual for my 2019 model which has the redesigned rear wall with higher lights and a low rack that is stuck on rather than bolted states:
"Your vehicle is fitted with the mounting points for a Fiamma Pro-C bike rack as standard. For further details, please consult your dealer or our Service Department. The maximum mass of the rack and cycles combined is 60 kg."
So the weight limit came down 7.5 kg (or 10 kg if the heavier e-bike rack was fitted). When I bought my van in 2019, the dealer told me it was not suitable for e-bikes. I don't know if he meant the rack or the fixings. I assume he meant the fixings as an e-bike rack could easily have been fitted. He didn't say a lighting board would be required which reduces the bike load by 2 kg.
A-S have now reduced the weight limit by a further 10 kg and said that e-bikes should not be carried and nor should the heavier e-bike version of the rack be fitted. So if we accept a lighting board is now a legal requirement, the maximum push bike only load including a lock, cover and rear marker board has come down from 60 kg to 40.5 kg. If the lock, cover and rear marker board weigh 5 kg, the rack should be good for two 17.75 kg push bikes although my preference is for them to be lighter or only carry one which is what I am now doing.
I think the solution for those with the newer back wall who wish to carry two e-bikes is to fit a tow bar mounted rack which for the 3500 kg Broadways will probably require the rear axle to be up-plated. (see https://www.autosleeper-ownersforum.com/t43943-up-plating-a-broadway) I'm not sure if the SWB 3500 kg Nuevo can be up-plated any more than it already has been.
Picking up on Bargee's points, the Fiamma rack comes with a red ratchet strap to make the bikes more secure on the rack and stop them wobbling about. If it is fitted vertically it will also help to reduce bounce. I don't think there are any suitable fixing points for eye bolts. My bike is quite tall which means I can just see the top of it through the rear mirror and the bottom of rear kitchen window which I have always found to be reassuring! I don't think CC would have that reassurance with his End Bathroom model but maybe the reversing camera will give that.
Caraman- Member
-
Posts : 3689
Joined : 2019-04-19
Location : SALISBURY
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
Web link please.
Caraman wrote:
I've just noticed this on the Auto-Sleeper website for all the coachbuilts:
The installation of the Fiamma Cycle Carrier Mounting Rails on the backs of Auto-Sleeper coachbuilt ranges has been specifically designed for the standard Fiamma Pro C range of cycle carriers and under no circumstances should any E-Bike carrier, Fiamma or otherwise be fitted to these rails nor shall Existing Fiamma Pro C carriers be upgraded by fitting the Fiamma Kit Upgrade E Bike.
It seems that Auto-Sleepers are saying if you want to carry e-bikes you need a tow bar mounted bike rack with all that that entails for the user payload and rear axle mass.
John McHale- Member
-
Posts : 24
Joined : 2021-08-21
Location : Dudley
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
Cymro is relieved! here are 3 photos, one showing the exterior of the van, where you can see that the wind-up elevating rack is secured by four fixings. Each fixing seems to have a bolt either side of the vertical rail, going into the van. I assume that those bolts go through the reinforcing wooden panels referred to by Caraman. The second shows where the top and bottom fixings come through into the bathroom, where they are covered by white Fiamma plastic covers; and the third shows what lies behind a cover: a metal plate with 2 small nuts. I expect that those nuts secure the bolts shown in the first photo. The centre hole in the plate is empty. I wonder what it was for?Caraman wrote:.... I wonder if the fixings have been bolted through as per the Fiamma installation manual in which case Cymro may have nothing to worry about.
Cymro
Cymro- Donator
-
Posts : 3662
Joined : 2011-06-05
Location : Caerdydd - Cardiff
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo ES
Vehicle Year : 2015
CC likes this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
Caraman- Member
-
Posts : 3689
Joined : 2019-04-19
Location : SALISBURY
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
The installation of the Fiamma Cycle Carrier Mounting Rails on the backs of Auto-Sleeper coachbuilt ranges has been specifically designed for the standard Fiamma Pro C range of cycle carriers and under no circumstances should any E-Bike carrier, Fiamma or otherwise be fitted to these rails nor shall Existing Fiamma Pro C carriers be upgraded by fitting the Fiamma Kit Upgrade E Bike.
John McHale- Member
-
Posts : 24
Joined : 2021-08-21
Location : Dudley
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
That's right but it has only appeared very recently on their website perhaps because of problems they have had. If someone had bought their Nuevo as I did in 2019 and hadn't kept up to date with what is said for the later models on the website and in later handbooks, perhaps through this Forum, they wouldn't know any of this or that the total weight limit including the rack, lighting board, cover, marker board, locks etc has gone down from 60 kg to 50 kg.John McHale wrote:The following appears under the technical section of the on line details of the Nuevo and other models:
The installation of the Fiamma Cycle Carrier Mounting Rails on the backs of Auto-Sleeper coachbuilt ranges has been specifically designed for the standard Fiamma Pro C range of cycle carriers and under no circumstances should any E-Bike carrier, Fiamma or otherwise be fitted to these rails nor shall Existing Fiamma Pro C carriers be upgraded by fitting the Fiamma Kit Upgrade E Bike.
Caraman- Member
-
Posts : 3689
Joined : 2019-04-19
Location : SALISBURY
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
John McHale likes this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
_________________
Get a life..... Get an Auto-Sleeper!
CC- Moderator
-
Posts : 3844
Joined : 2011-02-05
Member Age : 59
Location : North Norfolk
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
The problem is that there is a large void behind the fibreglass that our Fiamma fixings are stuck to. You can see/feel the void if you get under the back of the van and look and feel upwards. If you drum your hand on the fibreglass you can tell its hollow behind. The best that could probably be done is to fit bolts through the fibreglass but not through the wall as per your previous van and Cymro's. However, if this was to be a retrofit, I would have thought the glue that is holding the fixings at the moment would have to be broken to put the bolts in and then it would have to be re-glued as belt and braces. Preparation for gluing is all important so the old glue would all have to be removed. From Paul's earlier post it looks as though racks have been refitted with bolts but I wonder if that was after the glue had already parted company. I also don't know if this increases the load that the fixings can take.CC wrote:Wonder if the same fixings with the spreader plates on Cymro’s rack the same as what our last Broadway had can be added to our racks on the later models, if it were possible I’m guessing these fixing plates would be located in the unit beneath the wash basin & probably either side of the wash basin on an end bathroom model ?
Caraman- Member
-
Posts : 3689
Joined : 2019-04-19
Location : SALISBURY
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
CC likes this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
_________________
Get a life..... Get an Auto-Sleeper!
CC- Moderator
-
Posts : 3844
Joined : 2011-02-05
Member Age : 59
Location : North Norfolk
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2019
Cymro likes this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
A further thought. I suspect the bolting through is a necessity when the glue has failed as it will have pulled the screws out of the wooden fillet which I think are there. If so, new screws won't hold in the damaged wood so it has to be a bolt all the way through.CC wrote:I never was a fan of the newer back end design, even less so now I’m finding all this out…
Caraman- Member
-
Posts : 3689
Joined : 2019-04-19
Location : SALISBURY
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
CC likes this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
"Autosleepers bike rack problems.
Just received my bike rack fitting kit I ordered direct from Auto-Sleepers for my 2022 Nuevo. Very good service, £11 posted.
Goodness knows how it fits a what the heavy steel guides are for."
_________________
Nice to be important but more important to be nice
Paulmold- Donator
-
Posts : 26473
Joined : 2011-02-21
Member Age : 73
Location : North East Wales
Auto-Sleeper Model : Sussex Duo
Vehicle Year : 2010
CC likes this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
_________________
Get a life..... Get an Auto-Sleeper!
CC- Moderator
-
Posts : 3844
Joined : 2011-02-05
Member Age : 59
Location : North Norfolk
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2019
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
_________________
Nice to be important but more important to be nice
Paulmold- Donator
-
Posts : 26473
Joined : 2011-02-21
Member Age : 73
Location : North East Wales
Auto-Sleeper Model : Sussex Duo
Vehicle Year : 2010
CC and Caraman like this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
"It's to improve the mounting which is showing sings of coming adrift."
So again I ask 'why don't AS fit this at the build stage'?
_________________
Nice to be important but more important to be nice
Paulmold- Donator
-
Posts : 26473
Joined : 2011-02-21
Member Age : 73
Location : North East Wales
Auto-Sleeper Model : Sussex Duo
Vehicle Year : 2010
CC likes this post
Re: Fiamma Bike Rack Failure
John McHale- Member
-
Posts : 24
Joined : 2021-08-21
Location : Dudley
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo
Vehicle Year : 2019
Page 3 of 8 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
» Fiamma 200 DJ bike rack
» Fiamma bike rack.
» Fiamma Bike Rack
» Fiamma bike rack on Nuevo
The Auto-Sleeper Motorhome Owners Forum (ASOF) :: Auto-Sleeper Motorhome Forums :: Auto-Sleeper "Coachbuilt Motorhomes" Forum